The three emperors' club by Timothy Davies

History has a particularly cruel sense of humour. Eight decades after Yalta, when Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin carved the emerging post-war order into strategic understandings, the world appears to be flirting with another grand bargain. This time, the cast is Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. The furniture might be different, the microphones more sophisticated, and the photographs considerably more theatrical, but the underlying temptation remains depressingly familiar: the belief that the planet belongs to those powerful enough to negotiate its ownership.

Call it diplomacy. Call it strategic realism. Call it whatever fashionable expression the foreign-policy establishment invents to disguise its embarrassment. When three powerful men begin discussing the political future of continents without the meaningful participation of the people who inhabit them, we are not witnessing the triumph of diplomacy. We are witnessing the rehabilitation of imperial arrogance.

The most dangerous element of this emerging geopolitical imagination is its casual treatment of sovereignty as a negotiable commodity. Ukraine becomes a territorial question. Taiwan becomes a strategic inconvenience. Europe becomes a security arrangement to be adjusted according to American preferences and Russian demands. The Global South becomes an enormous chessboard, populated by governments expected to understand their place in somebody else's strategic calculations.

Putin has already demonstrated what happens when a powerful state decides that its neighbour's sovereignty is an historical misunderstanding. His invasion of Ukraine was not merely an act of military aggression; it was an assault on the fundamental principle that nations possess the right to determine their own political destiny.

Yet the disturbing possibility of a great-power settlement is that the aggressor might eventually be rewarded with precisely the political concessions that aggression was intended to obtain.

What message would that send? That borders are permanent only until somebody sufficiently powerful decides otherwise. That international law is binding on the weak and negotiable for the strong. That military violence can eventually become an acceptable instrument of territorial bargaining, provided the perpetrator possesses nuclear weapons and sufficient diplomatic leverage. This is not peace. It is the internationalisation of extortion.

Europe should be particularly alarmed. Not because it possesses some immaculate record of geopolitical innocence, but because it has spent decades constructing an institutional identity around the rejection of precisely this kind of power politics.

The European Union was supposed to represent something more sophisticated than the nineteenth-century balance of power: cooperation, institutional restraint, economic interdependence and the gradual replacement of coercion with law. A three-man geopolitical boardroom would expose the fragility of that ambition.

If Washington negotiates European security with Moscow while treating European governments as spectators, the Atlantic alliance becomes something resembling a property-management arrangement. If Beijing and Washington discuss Taiwan's future without Taiwanese participation, democratic self-determination becomes a decorative principle. If Russia is allowed to dictate the security architecture of Eastern Europe, then the European project discovers that its carefully constructed political vocabulary has not abolished imperialism. It has merely made imperialism considerably more difficult to discuss politely.

Europe cannot simultaneously defend Ukrainian sovereignty and accept that Russian security preferences automatically determine Ukraine's permissible political choices. Nor can it proclaim strategic autonomy while waiting for invitations to meetings where its own security is negotiated.

For much of the Global South, this spectacle would not represent a new geopolitical crisis. It would represent an old humiliation wearing expensive new suits.

Colonial borders, imposed economic arrangements, proxy wars and externally engineered political settlements have repeatedly demonstrated what happens when powerful outsiders claim superior knowledge of other societies' futures.

The emerging multipolar world was supposed to correct that historical imbalance. Instead, multipolarity risks becoming nothing more than a multiplication of imperial centres.

Three competing superpowers do not automatically produce a more democratic international system. They can just as easily produce three competing spheres of domination, each demanding obedience from its neighbours and each invoking sovereignty whenever its own interests require protection.

The answer is not to reject diplomacy between powerful states. Great powers must communicate, negotiate and manage dangerous rivalries. Nuclear confrontation is not a particularly attractive alternative to difficult conversations.

But diplomacy without accountability, representation and international law becomes something else entirely.

The United Nations Charter was not written to provide decorative language for summit communiqués. Its principles concerning sovereign equality, territorial integrity and the prohibition of aggressive force are supposed to constrain power, not merely describe its preferences.

A genuine peace settlement must include those whose lives, territories and political freedoms are at stake. Ukraine cannot be negotiated into submission. Taiwan cannot be reduced to a bargaining chip. Europe cannot outsource its security. The Global South cannot be expected to applaud another redistribution of influence.

The world does not need three emperors, three competing maps or three gentlemen deciding how much sovereignty everybody else can afford.

It needs something infinitely more difficult: powerful states accepting that their power does not confer ownership of the planet. Yalta was supposed to be a historical warning. Apparently, for some politicians, it remains an attractive business model.


The Polytechnic anniversary: Democracy still has unfinished business in Greece by Thanos Kalamidas

Every November, Greece returns to the gates of the Athens Polytechnic, carrying flowers, slogans, memories and an uncomfortable question: What exactly did we do with the freedom for which an entire generation dared to bleed?

The Polytechnic uprising of November 1973 was not merely a student rebellion against a military dictatorship. It was an eruption of dignity against fear, a refusal to accept that Greece belonged to colonels, bayonets, informers and political cowards. Its message was brutally simple: authority without freedom is oppression, patriotism without democracy is a lie, and silence in the face of injustice is complicity.

Fifty-three years later, that message remains painfully alive. Perhaps more alive than the political establishment would comfortably admit.

The anniversary arrives under the government of Kyriakos Mitsotakis, an administration increasingly associated by its critics with authoritarian reflexes, institutional arrogance, scandals, corruption allegations, surveillance controversies and a disturbing concentration of political and economic power. Calling the government far-right is a political judgement, not a neutral description, but its increasingly conservative, security-driven and exclusionary tendencies deserve relentless scrutiny. And the allegations and controversies surrounding its governance have become an uncomfortable question about the condition of Greek democracy itself.

The problem is not simply Mitsotakis. The problem is a political culture that repeatedly mistakes electoral victory for unlimited permission, parliamentary majority for institutional ownership, and public accountability for an irritating interruption of executive convenience.

Democracy is not the privilege of the government to administer. It is the permanent right of citizens to challenge, question, expose and eventually dismiss those who govern them. This is precisely where the Polytechnic becomes dangerous to contemporary political complacency.

The uprising was not a comfortable constitutional ceremony. It was not a carefully choreographed television spectacle featuring politicians laying wreaths before returning to their protected offices. It was resistance. Students occupied a university, broadcast their demands, challenged the regime and confronted a dictatorship that ultimately crushed the revolt with a tank and brutal repression. The uprising became a decisive symbol of resistance, although the military dictatorship itself survived until July 1974.

Its legacy cannot be reduced to a yearly ritual of commemorative speeches, carefully selected photographs and political representatives competing to inherit the moral authority of dead students.

There is something obscene about politicians invoking the Polytechnic while tolerating the erosion of democratic safeguards. There is something equally obscene about political parties treating its memory as exclusive property, a historical trademark to be exploited whenever electoral circumstances become inconvenient.

The dead belong to history. Their message belongs to everyone. And that message is not merely anti-dictatorship. It is anti-authoritarian, anti-corruption, anti-fear and profoundly pro-democratic. It demands independent institutions, a genuinely independent judiciary, free journalism, parliamentary accountability, transparent government and citizens who refuse to become spectators in their own political existence.

It also demands something more uncomfortable: the courage to recognise that democracy can decay without tanks in the streets. A democracy may retain elections while losing its institutional integrity. It may retain newspapers while intimidating journalists. It may retain parliament while hollowing out accountability. It may retain constitutional language while political power becomes increasingly insulated from scrutiny.

The anniversary should therefore not be a national exercise in nostalgia. Greece does not need another sentimental photograph of democracy. It needs democracy functioning properly. The Polytechnic belongs neither to Mitsotakis nor to his opponents, neither to the government nor to the political establishment that has repeatedly failed Greece.

It belongs to those who refuse corruption, fear and political impunity. Every November, the gates remind Greece that freedom was not handed down by respectable politicians. It was demanded by people who understood that silence has a price. The most faithful tribute to the Polytechnic is not a wreath. It is resistance whenever power forgets that democracy belongs to the people.


When big brother learns your face by Jennifer Stephenson

Democracy rarely dies with a gunshot anymore. Sometimes it dies with a camera, a fingerprint scanner and a little green light blinking above a supermarket entrance.

Imagine a world where you have committed no crime, broken no law, threatened nobody and challenged no government. Yet somebody knows where you went, whom you met, what you purchased, what you read, which political opinions you explored and what you said in a supposedly private conversation. Your face has become an identification document, your mobile phone a tracking device, your online behaviour a psychological profile and your daily movements a permanent invitation to scrutiny. Welcome to the modern panopticon. You do not need to be watched every minute. You only need to know that you might be.

The most disturbing development of the digital age is not simply the accumulation of personal information. It is the gradual destruction of anonymity, that supposedly suspicious and increasingly unfashionable human privilege of existing without having to explain yourself to somebody.

Privacy has become a marketing slogan, a box to tick in an application and an inconvenience to be negotiated between corporations, governments and citizens. We are told that surveillance makes us safer, biometric identification makes society more efficient and artificial intelligence makes the monitoring of populations more intelligent. Apparently, the price of convenience is surrendering the right to be left alone. What a magnificent bargain, particularly when the people making it are not the people paying for it.

The alliance between state surveillance and corporate data collection is particularly sinister. Governments possess the authority to investigate, regulate and punish. Corporations possess the infrastructure, technology and extraordinary quantities of personal information. Together, they create an ecosystem in which the distinction between public security and commercial exploitation becomes increasingly difficult to recognise.

Facial recognition, biometric databases, predictive policing, location tracking and algorithmic profiling are no longer futuristic fantasies. They are becoming ordinary instruments of administration. Their advocates insist that innocent citizens have nothing to fear. This is perhaps the most intellectually dishonest argument of our time. Since when did innocence become conditional upon permanent transparency? A citizen should not have to demonstrate that they deserve privacy. Privacy is a democratic right, not a reward for obedient behaviour.

And there is something even more dangerous happening beneath this technological enthusiasm. Surveillance changes human behaviour long before it produces arrests, prosecutions or political persecution. People become cautious. They hesitate before attending demonstrations, supporting controversial causes, communicating with dissidents or expressing opinions that might attract unwanted attention. Journalists protect their sources less confidently. Whistleblowers reconsider their decisions. Minority communities become increasingly aware that their identities, associations and movements can be catalogued, interpreted and potentially weaponised. This is the chilling effect, and it is democracy's silent poison.

Anonymity has historically provided breathing space for political opposition, intellectual experimentation, artistic rebellion and unpopular ideas. It allows people to question authority without immediately becoming targets of authority. It permits citizens to explore thoughts before deciding whether to express them publicly. Without that protected space, freedom of expression becomes an exercise in carefully calculated self-censorship.

The defenders of unrestricted surveillance will inevitably invoke corruption, terrorism, organised crime and national security. These are genuine challenges, not imaginary excuses. Governments have legitimate responsibilities to investigate criminal activity and protect citizens. But legitimate objectives do not provide unlimited permission. Surveillance must be necessary, proportionate, independently supervised and subject to meaningful judicial oversight. Biometric databases cannot become permanent population registers simply because technology makes their creation possible.

Nor should private technology companies be permitted to determine the boundaries of civil liberties through opaque algorithms and commercial contracts. Who audits these systems? Who corrects their mistakes? Who compensates citizens wrongly identified as threats? And who prevents today's perfectly respectable administration from handing tomorrow's authoritarian government an extraordinarily efficient instrument of repression? These are not technical questions. They are questions about power.

The greatest danger is that societies will become accustomed to surveillance through convenience rather than coercion. We willingly exchange information for access, location histories for recommendations and biometric identifiers for faster transactions. Each individual concession appears harmless. Together, they construct an architecture of unprecedented visibility.

We should stop confusing technological progress with democratic progress. A society can possess extraordinary computing power, sophisticated security systems and perfectly functioning digital administration while becoming profoundly less free.

Democracy requires more than elections, parliaments and constitutions. It requires the possibility of disagreement, the protection of unpopular opinions and the freedom to organise without first appearing in somebody's database.

The right to remain anonymous is not the right to commit crimes in darkness. It is the right to live without permanent suspicion. When every face becomes a password, every movement becomes a record and every opinion becomes a data point, the citizen gradually transforms into a subject: measurable, predictable and manageable. And that is the final irony of the algorithmic panopticon. We built technology supposedly to give humanity greater control over its world, only to create systems that increasingly give institutions greater control over humanity.

Democracy does not necessarily collapse when somebody switches off the lights. Sometimes it survives beautifully illuminated, surrounded by cameras, watched by algorithms and populated by citizens who have forgotten what it feels like not to be observed.

The last refuge of freedom is the right to exist without being watched. Lose that, and the prison no longer needs walls.


Globalizzazione #Cartoon by Alex Vannini

 

Drawings, caricatures from Alex Vannini

For more Ovi Cartoons, HERE!
For more Alex Vannini illustrations, HERE!


Poverty alleviation or poverty elevation? By Tunde Akande

Tinubu is dancing over the graves of the poor. Who says he will not win in 2027? If you say he will not win, just know you have been daydreaming.

Nigerian politicians are very heartless and wicked. They have no shame and they ply their trade without scruples. In Nigeria, politicians are a special breed of Homo sapiens. How can anybody who claims to serve the people say he is not in the trade because of God but because of himself? God is not at all in their mind. They are Christians and Muslims but they are most likely destined for hell because they are extremely wicked.

By the time you read this, President Bola Tinubu will be back from Makkah, where he went to attend the Umrah. He went with some governors and other officials to pray to a God who they think is dumb and blind. Bola Tinubu went during the 2023 elections. He said it publicly after he won the election or selection that when “the battle became very tough, I went to pray.” Muhammadu Buhari, the president that preceded him, who as we were told publicly recently by Hakeem Baba Ahmed, the Chairman of Peoples Redemption Party (PRP), resisted Bola Tinubu’s ambition to become president, also went to Umrah to pray to the same Allah. I was also in the house of Sarafadeen Alli, the APC gubernatorial candidate for Oyo State on the day he also traveled to Makkah for Umrah. If these politicians knew God, they would stay in their duty posts to serve the people well and not run from pillar to post to seek a God they don’t know with their retinue of marabouts.

If Tinubu and his retinue of Alfa and marabouts prayed to Allah to make him president, Muhammadu Buhari must have prayed to the same Allah that Tinubu be not made president. Who then will Allah hear? Well, we can say Allah heard Bola Tinubu because he won the presidency and got installed. But did Allah act in the best interest of Nigerians? If he did, why is there severe hunger and starvation in the land? Why are there massive deaths in Nigeria? Why is there such massive deception in government? Is Allah about deception and lying? Why are the politicians destroying the people so easily as they do and nothing seems to be done about it?

They know Nigerians and they have designed perfect strategies to capture them. The people have no will at all. They are not able to resist. They are at the mercy of these politicians. They leave people so poor that the people have become so dependent that they can’t think for themselves again. I’m witnessing such wickedness as this season of politicking kicks off. According to a report, Hon. Remi Oseni who is seeking to become the senator to represent Ibadan South in the next senate, came to Ward 3 in Kobomoje area in Ibadan and gave the promise of some millions of naira to the people.

He laid down a curse that anybody who would not allow the money to get to the people on the lowest rung of the ladder would suffer certain consequences. He told the audience that the money he distributes around was given to him by President Bola Tinubu and that it must produce results in the election. In Ward 9 in Olunloyo Street, Kudeti, Ibadan, Remi Oseni did not turn up for a planned campaign but sent a representative who gave promises in millions of naira. No curse was placed, but when the promise was fulfilled, it threw the entire area into bloodshed. A youth euphemistically so called because in real sense he is a thug, eloped with the one million naira that was transferred into his account for his fellow thugs.

And dazzling cutlasses shining at both edges was deployed to cut, cutting not trees but humans. The mutilated body of a victim was brought before a pharmacy storekeeper to be treated. The pharmacy storekeeper, perhaps out of fear, refused to treat the wounded person. He declared that he does not treat such cases, and that the bearers of the wounded should go to the hospital. What happened thereafter was not known but cutlasses continued to blaze. What was the cause and who was the cause? It was Remi Oseni and his million naira gift.

When Remi Oseni came to campaign, he did not come prepared with any manifesto for Tinubu or for his party, APC, neither did he come to share his own manifesto or one for his party, APC. He came to share money. When he told them Tinubu had given him such huge money to share and that the leaders must ensure it reached the lowest rung of the ladder, he could have done that just to give a boost to Tinubu’s campaign or to demonstrate the usual loyalty to the boss in Nigeria which is important to win favour. Who knows, Tinubu may pick Remi Oseni to be a minister. That’s where the biggest money in the government is stolen. We have heard unconfirmed allegations that to win a slot in the cabinet a candidate has to pay billions of naira in bribes. This is not a rumour. The allegation was made on Arise Television by the spokesperson of APC Campaign Council, Alwan Hassan.

But what may give Remi Oseni a juicy cabinet appointment if he wants it and give Bola Tinubu a return to the juicy presidency produced death in Ward 9, Olunloyo Street, Kudeti, Ibadan. I live down the street and the cousin who brought the sad news to me said while I slept peacefully in my house, down the street, death was moving from house to house. I did not eat in their “gbi” and certainly I will not die in their “gbi” was my response. When a Yoruba says that, he is saying what the Bible calls “sowing and reaping.” Since I did not take part in the sharing of Oseni/Tinubu largesse, I’m certainly not going to reap the death it produced.

I had warned a cousin about the evil effect of taking money from the politicians in order to vote for them. It was a trap and insanity, I had told him. But he would not listen. I had told some other women too who live in the same house with me but they pretended to listen but they didn’t. When the opportunity came they collected the money. According to news that came to me, out of the money sent to Ward 9 by Remi Oseni, four million naira was skimmed by the landlords. Every hierarchy through which the money passed stole something.

For example, my cousin through whom the news came was to collect five thousand naira but the hierarchy who gave him told him he had borrowed one thousand naira out of it. So from the seven houses the hierarchy distributed the largesse to, he stole seven thousand. This is the opportunity the politicians exploit. They know the people are poor and greedy, all they need is to keep them poor and continue to throw pieces of bones to them as unto dogs and quickly they will rush into it. They could kill themselves in the process and the politicians do not care a hoot. If they die it is just minus some figures from the population.

The cycle of evil goes on and on and the people remain pauperized and all the money goes to the elite who service their other colleagues with the money meant for the entire populace. Alhaji Samad Rabiu, the owner of BUA Cement, said with President Bola Tinubu’s removal of subsidy and the floating of naira, he doesn’t need to go to CBN for dollars again. He could get all he needed easily. The capitalist spoke well. He said what we poor have always known, President Bola Tinubu removed money from us and transferred the little we had to the rich who control 98 percent of the nation’s wealth already. Now the poor have nothing.

President Bola Tinubu was strategic in his thinking. By removing the subsidy and by floating the naira, Tinubu has found a strategy to keep the people perpetually poor and dependent on him. By throwing crumbs at them, especially in the few months before the election, he can keep them voting for him perpetually. If former President Olusegun Obasanjo knew this, he would still be president till now and not lose his third term bid, however unconstitutional it is. When Tinubu introduced his multiple poverty alleviation programme, his subsidy removal and naira floating policies ensured a 30 percent food inflation because nobody grew any food and the bandits made sure the few who cultivated any piece of farmland got kidnapped and paid huge ransom. In no time these poverty alleviation programmes became poverty elevation programmes. Tinubu is dancing over the graves of the poor. Who says he will not win in 2027? If you say he will not win, just know you have been daydreaming. You need to wake up, Tinubu has gotten Nigeria by the jugular.

First Published in METRO

***********************

Tunde Akande is both a journalist and pastor. He earned a Master's degree in Mass Communication from the University of Lagos.


Ma-Siri & Co #134 #Cartoon by Thanos Kalamidas

 

Ma-Siri is a mother, a grandmother and a very active social life,
searching for the meaning of life among other things and her glasses.

For more Ma-Siri & Alexa, HERE!
For more Ovi Cartoons, HERE!


COP31: The planet on trial, the fossils in the jury by Thanos Kalamidas

There was a moment in Paris - and I was there, witness - when humanity pretended it had finally understood the emergency. Eleven years later, the climate conference has become an extraordinary monument to international hypocrisy, everybody knows what must be done, everybody knows who is refusing to do it and everybody continues pretending that another conference might somehow change the plot.

The Paris Agreement of 2015 was presented as a historic breakthrough. After decades of diplomatic paralysis, governments supposedly agreed that climate change was not some distant inconvenience for future generations, but an existential threat unfolding before our eyes. The Kyoto Protocol had already demonstrated the limitations of international climate diplomacy; its compromises, exemptions, and political evasions left the impression of a wounded instrument rather than a decisive response. Paris was supposed to be different. It was not.

The agreement was an achievement of diplomacy, certainly but also an extraordinary exercise in lowering expectations. Binding ambition was replaced by voluntary national pledges, accountability softened by political convenience, and the collective objective of limiting warming became increasingly detached from the actual behaviour of governments and industries. The planet received promises. The fossil-fuel economy received breathing space.

The COPs that followed became an annual ritual of increasingly familiar disappointment. Ministers arrived, negotiators negotiated, environmental organisations protested, scientists warned, and corporate representatives circulated through the corridors with the comfortable confidence of people who understood that the system was not designed to threaten their interests. There were announcements, declarations, roadmaps, and carefully negotiated phrases. There was also the continuing expansion of fossil-fuel production, the persistence of subsidies, and the remarkable ability of political leaders to describe insufficient action as historical progress.

Then came Donald Trump, the American president who treated climate science as an inconvenience and environmental responsibility as an ideological enemy. His withdrawal from the Paris Agreement was not just an administrative decision. It was a declaration that even the most modest international climate commitments could be sacrificed to the political theatre of nationalism, industrial nostalgia, and billionaire-friendly deregulation.

His return to the White House made the message unmistakably uglier. Climate policy became another battlefield in the war against scientific institutions, international cooperation, and the very idea that governments have responsibilities extending beyond the next electoral cycle.

And now, ten COPs after Paris, we arrive at COP31, confronting a political landscape in which authoritarian instincts, environmental hostility, and the worship of economic power threaten to suffocate whatever remains of international climate ambition.

The location and political symbolism of a conference matter. They matter enormously when democratic accountability, environmental protection, and the rights of ordinary citizens are being squeezed by governments that confuse national sovereignty with personal political authority. Hosting climate diplomacy in such an environment raises an uncomfortable question: can a conference genuinely defend the planet while its political surroundings undermine democracy, public participation, and environmental responsibility?

But the real scandal is larger than any individual host or president. The climate crisis has exposed the obscene imbalance between political responsibility and economic power. Governments can negotiate endlessly because the industries responsible for the crisis have acquired extraordinary influence over the political machinery expected to regulate them. Fossil-fuel corporations do not need to sabotage every conference. They merely need the world to move slowly enough for their investments to remain profitable.

Meanwhile, ordinary people pay the bill. Farmers confront increasingly unpredictable seasons. Communities experience devastating floods, fires, and heatwaves. Families lose homes, livelihoods, and sometimes their lives. Countries that contributed least to atmospheric destruction are frequently among those suffering most severely from its consequences. And what does the international community offer? Another conference.

This is not an argument against the United Nations. Quite the opposite. Without international cooperation, the climate crisis becomes an even more dangerous competition between nations protecting their economic privileges while abandoning everybody else. The UN remains indispensable precisely because the atmosphere recognises neither borders nor presidential egos.

But conferences cannot substitute for courage. Agreements cannot substitute for implementation. And diplomatic language cannot substitute for political confrontation with the industries and interests obstructing change.

COP31 should therefore be judged not by its photographs, declarations, or carefully choreographed optimism, but by whether governments are prepared to confront fossil-fuel dependence, enforce meaningful commitments, finance climate adaptation, and protect those already suffering the consequences. Otherwise, we should stop pretending that these gatherings are saving the planet. They are becoming expensive annual memorial services for political responsibility.

The tragedy is not that humanity lacks the knowledge, technology, or resources to act. The tragedy is that humanity has developed an extraordinary capacity to understand its own destruction while negotiating politely with the people making money from it.

The atmosphere is not waiting for another diplomatic breakthrough. Neither are the forests, oceans, glaciers, or millions of people living on the increasingly fragile margins of this supposedly civilised world. Paris offered a promise. The subsequent COPs offered excuses.

COP31 must confront the uncomfortable possibility that the international climate process itself is approaching a credibility collapse. Not because conversation is useless, but because conversation without consequences eventually becomes another instrument of deception.

The planet does not need another historic agreement. It needs governments capable of making history by finally breaking with the interests destroying it.


The Commonwealth of cowards by Solomon Mensah

There is something particularly obscene about an international organisation that can issue stern warnings, establish deadlines, express profound concern, convene distinguished meetings, produce beautifully worded declarations and then quietly return to lunch when nothing changes. Welcome to the Commonwealth, where democracy is apparently a cherished family value, provided nobody makes the family uncomfortable.

Tanzania has become another uncomfortable test of the international community's commitment to human rights. And, judging by the response, the Commonwealth seems considerably more interested in preserving diplomatic relationships than defending the principles upon which its existence supposedly rests.

The case of opposition leader Tundu Lissu should have been impossible to ignore. Arrested in April 2025 and charged with treason after demanding electoral reforms, Lissu spent more than eighteen months in detention. The treason charge was eventually dismissed, but on 6 November 2026, he was convicted of incitement and sentenced to four years in prison. His legal ordeal has unfolded against a background of political intimidation, restrictions on opposition activity and an increasingly hostile environment for democratic dissent.

Meanwhile, Tanzania's October 2025 elections were followed by deadly violence. Hundreds of people were killed, according to the findings of a government-appointed commission, while families continue searching for answers about missing relatives. Human rights organisations have documented killings, disappearances, arbitrary arrests and allegations of excessive force by security personnel. A year later, meaningful accountability remains conspicuously absent.

This is not simply a dispute between an African government and its political opposition. It is a question of whether citizens possess the right to challenge those governing them without risking imprisonment, torture or death.

The Commonwealth knew enough to demand action. It established expectations and deadlines concerning Lissu's detention, democratic reforms and accountability for election-related violence. Those deadlines expired without decisive consequences. Even the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in Antigua and Barbuda, held from 1 to 4 November 2026, passed without the Tanzania crisis receiving the political attention its seriousness demanded. And there lies the institutional embarrassment.

The Commonwealth likes to describe itself as a community founded upon democracy, human rights, the rule of law and the protection of fundamental freedoms. These are attractive words, particularly when printed in official declarations. But principles that disappear whenever their enforcement becomes diplomatically inconvenient are not principles. They are public relations.

Of course, international diplomacy is complicated. Tanzania is an important regional actor, strategically positioned in East Africa, with significant economic, security and development relationships. Nobody seriously expects international organisations to solve political crises through theatrical ultimatums or indiscriminate punishment. But there is a difference between diplomatic engagement and diplomatic surrender.

The Commonwealth possesses political mechanisms, including the possibility of suspension from membership under its democratic principles. It does not need to impose economic sanctions automatically every time a member violates democratic standards. It does, however, need to demonstrate that persistent violations carry consequences. Otherwise, its warnings become decorative ornaments in the corridors of international diplomacy.

And what message does this send to other governments? That an opposition leader can remain imprisoned, election violence can disappear into an administrative investigation, and international criticism can be managed through patience, promises and carefully choreographed meetings?

There is also something deeply patronising about treating African governments as though democratic accountability must always take second place to geopolitical considerations. African citizens do not deserve weaker democratic protections because their governments happen to be strategically useful. Their rights are not diplomatic bargaining chips.

The tragedy is not that the Commonwealth lacks language. It has plenty. It lacks the political courage to make its language mean something. The people killed in Tanzania cannot be brought back by another communiqué. Their families cannot bury their grief beneath diplomatic expressions of concern. Tundu Lissu cannot recover eighteen months of freedom through another international statement.

The Commonwealth now faces a choice: defend the principles it advertises or accept that its credibility is slowly becoming another casualty of political convenience. Democracy cannot survive on declarations. Human rights cannot depend on the strategic importance of the country violating them. And an international organisation that repeatedly looks away should not be surprised when the world eventually stops looking towards it. Silence is not neutrality. It is a political decision. And in Tanzania, the price of that decision is being paid by the people who can least afford it.


The human body is not a subscription service by Kasie Hewitt

There was a time when athletes were expected to play the game, entertain the spectators and occasionally go home with a bruised knee, a broken nose or a magnificent story to tell. Today, apparently, they are expected to play until their bodies start filing formal complaints, travel across continents, perform on demand, smile for the cameras, satisfy sponsors, feed television schedules and remain permanently available to an international audience with the attention span of a goldfish and the betting habits of a casino addict.

Welcome to modern professional sport, where exhaustion is no longer an unfortunate consequence of competition. It is becoming a business model.

Something has gone badly wrong when the world's richest sporting organisations appear increasingly incapable of understanding a rather elementary biological principle: human beings need rest. Footballers are expected to survive domestic leagues, international tournaments, continental competitions, expanded club championships and national-team commitments. Tennis players are dragged through an almost endless travelling circus, collecting ranking points while their knees, backs and shoulders negotiate their own terms of surrender. American sports have perfected the commercial packaging of spectacle, turning seasons, playoffs and broadcasting windows into an industrial production line. Apparently, there is always another match to sell.

The problem is not that professional athletes are unwilling to work. Quite the opposite. These are extraordinarily disciplined people who have sacrificed childhoods, social lives and personal freedoms to reach the highest levels of their professions. Their competitive instinct is precisely what makes them vulnerable. Tell an elite athlete that missing a match might cost a place in the team, a contract, a sponsorship or a championship, and the pressure to continue becomes almost irresistible. The administrators understand this perfectly. They exploit it beautifully.

Behind the familiar language of sporting development, global expansion and improved fan engagement sits an increasingly vulgar commercial appetite. More fixtures mean more broadcasting rights, more advertising opportunities, more subscriptions, more merchandise and, inevitably, more opportunities for betting companies to turn every corner kick, penalty, serve and last-minute substitution into another financial transaction. The athlete becomes the raw material.

The human body is converted into statistics: kilometres covered, sprint intensity, recovery intervals, expected performance, injury probability and market value. Technology measures everything except the fundamental question of whether the person wearing the shirt can continue without damaging themselves.

And when the damage arrives? Sympathy, a medical statement, a photograph of a rehabilitation room and perhaps a motivational video about resilience. Resilience has become the convenient public-relations word for institutional irresponsibility.

There is something particularly cynical about celebrating an athlete's courage while ignoring the system that made playing through exhaustion financially or professionally necessary. We applaud dedication, but rarely question the people who keep adding matches to the calendar. We celebrate records, but ignore the bodies that pay for them. We praise sporting greatness while treating the possibility of long-term physical consequences as an unfortunate accounting expense.

This is not an argument against ambition, competition or commercial success. Professional sport is an industry, and athletes deserve to earn extraordinary rewards when their abilities generate extraordinary revenues. But commercial success cannot become an unlimited licence to consume human health. The solution requires something that sporting administrators seem increasingly allergic to: limits.

International federations, leagues and players' associations must establish enforceable annual workload limits, minimum recovery periods, protected off-seasons and independent medical authority to withdraw exhausted players without financial or contractual punishment. Competition organisers must stop expanding tournaments simply because another broadcasting contract makes the figures look attractive. And players must have meaningful representation in decisions concerning the calendars that govern their working lives.

Above all, betting and broadcasting interests must stop dictating the rhythm of sporting existence. Sport needs spectators, money and competition. It does not need an endless production line of exhausted bodies. A footballer is not a disposable streaming asset, a tennis player is not a travelling vending machine for ranking points, and an athlete is not a subscription service that must deliver fresh content every evening.

There is also a danger that the industry refuses to acknowledge: spectators might eventually become tired of watching exhausted athletes. The magic of elite sport lies in exceptional human performance, not in watching exceptionally wealthy organisations discover how far they can push a damaged human being before the medical team intervenes. The greatest sporting achievement should be the extraordinary performance, not the ability to survive the calendar.

Perhaps it is time for the people running international sport to remember something embarrassingly simple. The stadium can be rebuilt, the television contract renegotiated, the tournament expanded and the advertising inventory increased. But once you have broken the athlete, there is no commercial miracle that gives them their body back. And no amount of subscription revenue can make that acceptable.


Berserk Alert! #135 #Cartoon by Tony Zuvela

 

Tony Zuvela and his view of the world around us in a constant berserk alert!
For more Berserk Alert! HERE!
For more Ovi Cartoons, HERE!


Ian Glim #020 #cartoon by Thanos Kalamidas

 

A bewildered soul navigating global complexities armed
only with earnestness and a sharp, sarcastic wit.

For more Ian Glim, HERE!
For more Ovi Cartoons, HERE!


The three emperors' club by Timothy Davies

History has a particularly cruel sense of humour. Eight decades after Yalta, when Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin carved the emerging post-...