Police brutality is a reflection on western hypocrisy and the dangers of power by Sabine Fischer

Every year, March 15th marks the International Day Against Police Brutality, a day that resonates more profoundly today than ever before. Initially created to shed light on police violence around the world, it has morphed into a global call for change, echoing the outrage of marginalized communities that have long been silenced. What was once a reminder of police excesses in authoritarian regimes has transformed into a powerful indictment of the hypocrisy ingrained in many Western democracies.

In countries that pride themselves on upholding human rights and freedoms, the facade is cracking, revealing an institution that, far from safeguarding justice, has become a force of oppression. From the United States to France, Canada to the United Kingdom, police brutality has spread like an insidious stain, staining the reputation of democratic ideals and exposing the brutality lurking behind the so-called ‘civilized’ façade.

The paradox is difficult to ignore: Western democracies, who lecture the rest of the world on the importance of human rights, seem incapable of applying those very principles within their own borders. When it comes to the brutality of police officers, these countries often fail to hold their law enforcement accountable, instead shielding them with qualified immunity or vague policies that perpetuate impunity.

Take, for example, the infamous events surrounding George Floyd's murder in the United States. The graphic footage, now seared into our collective memory, painted a grim picture of what police are capable of when their power is left unchecked. Yet even after the conviction of the officer who killed Floyd, many others continue to act with impunity. How many more deaths must we witness before systemic change is implemented? The problem runs deeper than a few bad apples; it’s about a culture of power, control, and violence that is embedded within police institutions.

In France, a country that prided itself on its revolutionary ideals of liberty, equality, and fraternity, we’ve seen protests after protests in the streets of Paris against the excessive use of police force. From the brutal treatment of the “yellow vests” to the violent crackdowns on immigrant communities, it’s clear that the police are not just enforcing the law—they’re acting as a tool of repression against those who dare to challenge the status quo. And yet, the French government turns a blind eye to the growing calls for reform, using the same tired rhetoric of “protecting order” to justify this ongoing cycle of brutality.

Meanwhile, in the UK, the scandal of police violence extends to the handling of protests, with instances like the killing of Sarah Everard by a serving officer highlighting how deeply ingrained the problem is within law enforcement. The response of the police to protests following this tragic incident was as appalling as it was predictable: heavy-handed tactics, disproportionate force, and a complete disregard for the rights of citizens to voice their dissent.

The real issue here is not isolated incidents of brutality; it’s about the systemic nature of police violence. Across many Western countries, the culture of policing fosters an “us versus them” mentality, where officers believe they are above the law and that the people they are supposed to protect are inherently dangerous. This creates a toxic environment where violence becomes normalized, where aggression is seen as a legitimate response to minor infractions, and where empathy is an afterthought.

Police forces were originally designed to serve and protect, but somewhere along the line, they have morphed into a political tool, an instrument of state power designed to uphold the interests of the elite. Whether it’s cracking down on protesters, enforcing racist policies, or terrorizing marginalized communities, the police have become the enforcers of an unjust system. This is evident in the disproportionate targeting of Black, Indigenous, and people of colour (BIPOC) in countries like the US, where racial profiling remains rampant, or in Europe, where migrants and refugees are often subjected to harsh and discriminatory treatment by law enforcement.

What’s most disturbing is the way in which police brutality has become normalized. In many Western nations, there’s a disturbing tendency to dismiss the violence as “justified” or “necessary,” especially when it’s directed at marginalized communities. After all, who cares about the lives of the poor, the immigrant, or the protester, right? They’re simply disrupting the peace, so any violence used against them is seen as acceptable collateral damage. The public has been conditioned to accept these actions as a byproduct of maintaining order, but this logic is flawed.

Police brutality cannot be justified by the need to maintain public order. The moment we allow our law enforcement agencies to resort to violence as a tool of control, we risk undermining the very essence of democracy. The state’s monopoly on violence should never extend beyond the protection of its citizens; it should not be used as a method of oppression. The danger of normalizing brutality is that it teaches society that violence is an acceptable solution, and that those in power can act with impunity. It creates a toxic cycle where brutality is met with more brutality, and the victims, often the most vulnerable in society, are left to suffer in silence.

To truly honour the spirit of the International Day Against Police Brutality, we must demand more than empty platitudes or superficial reforms. We need real, systemic change. It starts with holding police accountable for their actions, ensuring that officers who engage in misconduct are prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. It also requires greater transparency in the way police departments operate, as well as robust oversight mechanisms to ensure that abuse of power is prevented before it starts.

But reform must go deeper than just holding individual officers accountable. It’s about dismantling the very culture that encourages the abuse of power. This means reevaluating the role of police in society, rethinking their relationship with marginalized communities, and moving toward a system of community-based safety that emphasizes conflict resolution, de-escalation, and social justice. It’s about recognizing that a society is only truly safe when everyone, regardless of race, class, or background, can walk down the street without the fear of violence.

As we observe the International Day Against Police Brutality this year, let us not simply pay lip service to the ideals of justice and equality. Let us not accept the status quo, where those who are sworn to protect us can abuse their power with impunity. We must confront the uncomfortable truth that police brutality is not just a problem in some far-off dictatorship, it’s a problem right here, in the heart of the Western world.

The fight for justice is not just about honouring the memory of those lost to police violence; it’s about demanding a world where such violence is no longer tolerated. A world where the police serve the people, not the other way around. This battle is far from over, but it’s one that we cannot afford to lose. Because if we do, we risk losing everything that we claim to stand for.

It’s time to end the silence. It’s time to fight for justice.


No comments:

Trump’s NATO power fantasy by Harry S. Taylor

It seems that every few years, Donald Trump finds a way to remind the world that his understanding of international alliances is less about...