Incompetence and corruption, the root causes for Nigeria’s Health Care collapse by Eze Ogbu

In recent years, Nigeria’s health care system has been in a state of persistent collapse. With dwindling resources, dilapidated infrastructure, and medical personnel fleeing the country for better opportunities abroad, the health sector is failing its citizens. This crisis is often attributed to a mix of incompetence and corruption within the government, leading to an overall breakdown in service delivery and public trust.

Nigeria’s health care system, which should ideally serve the over 200 million population, is crippled by inadequate funding, poor management, and obsolete facilities. Hospitals and clinics are often characterized by non-functional equipment, outdated medication, and unsanitary conditions. Patients frequently endure long wait times for subpar services, or worse, they’re turned away due to a lack of basic medical supplies or staff shortages. This state of decay has led to an increase in preventable deaths from diseases like malaria, cholera, and tuberculosis, as well as from complications during childbirth.

According to the World Health Organization (WHO), Nigeria accounts for approximately 20% of the global maternal mortality rate, with 814 deaths per 100,000 live births. The infant mortality rate is similarly alarming, as Nigeria ranks among the top five countries with the highest numbers of under-five deaths globally. With health care access being severely limited, particularly in rural areas, millions of Nigerians are left without essential medical services.

The issues within the Nigerian health care system are rooted in a deep-seated culture of government incompetence and corruption. The misallocation of funds, lack of accountability, and self-serving interests of political leaders have all played a role in the disintegration of the health care sector.

Despite the Abuja Declaration in 2001, where African Union countries, including Nigeria, committed to allocating at least 15% of their national budgets to health care, Nigeria consistently fails to meet this benchmark. In the 2023 budget, health care received less than 6% of the total allocation, reflecting a stark neglect of the sector. Moreover, what little is budgeted is often not fully disbursed, leading to insufficient resources for facilities, personnel, and essential drugs.

Another critical factor in the collapse is the mismanagement of funds. It is common knowledge that allocated resources are often siphoned off by government officials and contractors, resulting in unfinished projects and inadequately equipped health centres. This mismanagement is often covered up or ignored due to lack of oversight and accountability within the government and civil service.

For instance, the National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NPHCDA) has faced numerous allegations of financial impropriety, with millions of dollars in donor and public funds meant for health programs going unaccounted for. These funds, which could have been used to improve health infrastructure and provide essential medical supplies, are instead diverted for private gain.

Corruption and incompetence have also had a significant impact on health care workers. Medical professionals in Nigeria face low wages, poor working conditions, and delayed salaries, all of which contribute to their dissatisfaction and the resulting "brain drain." According to the Nigerian Medical Association (NMA), over 9,000 doctors have left the country in the last two years, seeking better opportunities abroad.

In a country where the doctor-patient ratio is already severely low at 1:5,000, compared to the WHO’s recommended ratio of 1:600, the departure of trained personnel has exacerbated the health care crisis. Hospitals and clinics are severely understaffed, leading to overworked doctors and nurses who are stretched to their limits, ultimately resulting in substandard care.

While government officials flaunt luxurious lifestyles, public hospitals in Nigeria continue to fall into disrepair. Inadequate infrastructure is one of the major challenges facing the health care system. Hospitals often lack basic amenities such as clean water, stable electricity, and functioning medical equipment. Reports have shown that many government hospitals cannot provide services such as x-rays, blood tests, or even simple surgeries due to broken or obsolete equipment.

The state of many Nigerian hospitals is a direct result of corruption in the procurement processes and inflated contracts. Funds earmarked for the construction or renovation of hospitals are frequently misappropriated, leaving projects abandoned or poorly executed. One notable example is the abandonment of the National Cancer Treatment Centre project in Abuja, despite billions of naira being allocated for its completion over the past decade.

The average Nigerian’s trust in the government’s ability to manage health care has waned considerably over the years. The majority of the population, particularly those in low-income brackets, cannot afford private health care or travel abroad for medical treatment like many political elites do. Consequently, they are left at the mercy of an underfunded and underperforming public health system.

This lack of confidence is not without consequence. When citizens lose faith in their health care system, they are less likely to seek preventive care, leading to increased morbidity and mortality rates. For example, routine immunizations and prenatal care visits have dropped sharply in rural areas where distrust of the system is highest. The direct consequence of these trends is the rise in outbreaks of preventable diseases and a growing burden of chronic illnesses.

International aid has played a significant role in propping up Nigeria’s health sector, with billions of dollars flowing in from organizations like WHO, UNICEF, and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. However, the positive impact of this aid is often undermined by corruption within the government. Aid meant to finance specific health programs, such as immunization drives or maternal health initiatives, frequently goes missing or is poorly managed, rendering these programs ineffective.

The Nigerian government’s response to these challenges has been largely characterized by rhetoric rather than tangible reforms. Promises of increased health budgets, anti-corruption campaigns, and capacity-building initiatives have rarely translated into concrete improvements in the sector. Efforts to implement universal health coverage or build a robust primary health care system have stalled due to inadequate political will and entrenched corruption.

The collapse of Nigeria’s health care system demands urgent and comprehensive reforms. The following recommendations aim to address the systemic issues plaguing the sector:

The Nigerian government must prioritize health care funding by increasing its budgetary allocation to meet the 15% target set by the Abuja Declaration. Moreover, strict transparency and accountability measures must be implemented to track disbursements and prevent misappropriation of funds. This could involve the use of digital platforms and independent audits to monitor spending.

The existing anti-corruption bodies, such as the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), should be empowered to investigate and prosecute cases of corruption in the health care sector. Additionally, whistleblower protection laws should be strengthened to encourage citizens and health workers to report corrupt practices without fear of retribution.

The government needs to invest heavily in health care infrastructure by upgrading and maintaining public hospitals and clinics. This should include modernizing equipment, ensuring reliable electricity and water supplies, and improving sanitation. Additionally, procurement processes should be streamlined and made transparent to curb the culture of inflated contracts and abandoned projects.

To prevent further brain drain, the Nigerian government must improve the working conditions and remuneration of health care workers. This could include revising salary structures, providing hazard allowances, and offering continuous training and development programs. Retention incentives, such as housing schemes and career advancement opportunities, should also be explored to encourage doctors and nurses to remain in the country.

One of the most effective ways to rebuild the health care system is to implement a sustainable and comprehensive universal health coverage program. This would involve pooling funds to provide essential health services to all Nigerians, regardless of income or location. Such a system could be financed through a combination of government revenue, donor contributions, and community-based health insurance schemes.

The collapse of Nigeria’s health care system is a result of years of government incompetence and pervasive corruption. The consequences of this collapse are felt most acutely by the poorest and most vulnerable citizens, who are denied access to basic medic

No comments:

ASEAN’s Multilateral Dilemma: Continuity and Change from NAM to BRICS by Anis H. Bajrektarevic & Evi Fitriani

 (No Asian Century without true multilateralism) ASEAN’s enduring strength has never been its ability to project power, but its capacity t...