From right-wing intellectual to America’s Rudolph Hess by John Reid

The last few years have seen an extraordinary transformation in American politics, one that should have been impossible in a functioning democracy. Once heralded as a right-wing intellectual, a man who spoke of the plight of the working class with an air of authenticity, JD Vance has now emerged as something far more dangerous. With his ascension to the vice presidency, he has become America’s own Rudolph Hess—the right-hand man of a movement dedicated to hatred, division, and prejudice.

There was a time when JD Vance was the poster child of the so-called “thoughtful conservative.” His book, Hillbilly Elegy, was widely read as an earnest examination of working-class despair, its struggles with poverty and addiction. He was the man who could supposedly bridge the gap between the intellectual elite and the forgotten Americans, the one who would prove that conservatism was not just for billionaires and war hawks. But power has a way of revealing one’s true character. Or perhaps, it has a way of dismantling carefully curated illusions.

Today, JD Vance is no longer a commentator on America’s divisions; he is an architect of them. He has embraced the language of grievance, turning cultural resentment into policy and paranoia into governance. Where once he claimed to stand for opportunity, he now stands for exclusion. Where once he bemoaned the loss of American unity, he now actively participates in its destruction, wielding fear as a political weapon. He has found his role in history not as a thinker but as a servant to the basest impulses of reactionary politics.

Like Hess, Vance operates under the shadow of a greater, more chaotic force. He does not lead the movement but amplifies it, legitimizing its worst tendencies with his Ivy League polish and carefully constructed persona. But let’s be clear: Hess was not just a mere follower of Hitler; he was a believer, a zealot who internalized the hatred and turned it into doctrine. Vance, too, has fully committed to the cause he once pretended to critique. He no longer questions the slide toward authoritarianism but accelerates it, giving it the intellectual veneer it so desperately craves.

His rhetoric has turned into something more than just the usual Republican dog whistles. He speaks in absolutes, in grand, sweeping condemnations of anyone who does not conform to his vision of America. Immigrants are no longer individuals but threats. The media is no longer a check on power but an enemy to be destroyed. Political opponents are no longer fellow Americans but internal enemies to be crushed. Every speech, every policy proposal, every statement echoes the same theme: division. An us-versus-them mentality that fuels his supporters' anger and solidifies his place as the loyal executor of the movement’s worst instincts.

It is no longer a matter of political disagreement or policy differences. Vance, like Hess before him, represents a deeper rot—a willingness to erode democracy from within, to trade principles for power, to sacrifice the very fabric of the nation in service of an ideology built on exclusion and domination. And as history has shown us, these men are often more dangerous than their masters. The strongmen, the demagogues, the larger-than-life figures of tyranny—they rise and fall. But the bureaucrats of hate, the architects of division, the men who make the machine run—they are the ones who ensure that destruction lingers long after the regime crumbles.

Vance’s transformation is not just a personal betrayal of whatever principles he once claimed to hold. It is a warning. A warning that America is not immune to the tides of history, that even a nation built on democracy can fall prey to the seductive appeal of reactionary rage. It is a reminder that the battle for the soul of a country is not won by moderates seeking common ground with those who wish to destroy it but by those willing to confront the creeping darkness head-on.

JD Vance is not just another politician who lost his way. He is a man who found exactly where he belongs—at the right hand of a movement that thrives on division, fear, and the steady erosion of everything America once claimed to stand for. And like all those before him who walked this path, history will remember him not as a leader, not as an intellectual, but as an accomplice.


No comments:

The carol fell silent in the rubble by Emma Schneider

The western Christmas spirit has died somewhere in the Gaza ruins, not with a bang but with a long, televised whimper. It did not vanish ov...