The apprentice presidency by Kingsley Cobb

In Donald Trump’s Washington, the business of governing has become indistinguishable from a television casting session. The candidates are assembled, the cameras are rolling, the egos are inflated, and somewhere in the background a man is waiting to announce who stays and who gets fired. America, apparently, is not a republic so much as an exceptionally expensive reality show and Donald Trump just put JD Vance and Marco Rubio through their paces as potential successors.

Two men, both ambitious, both calculating, both acutely aware that their political futures depend less on the American electorate than on the unpredictable mood of one elderly man in the Oval Office. They were not simply being observed. They were auditioning. And then Stephen Miller walked into the political theatre and stole the show.

It was an unexpected twist, although perhaps not an entirely surprising one. Miller, Trump's ideological attack dog and one of the most influential architects of his political agenda, has never needed an election campaign to exercise power. His influence comes from proximity, ideological loyalty and an almost pathological determination to turn political grievances into government policy. While Vance and Rubio may represent competing versions of a future Republican leadership, Miller represents something rather different: the machinery that could survive whoever occupies the presidency.

That is what makes this little succession spectacle considerably more interesting than the personalities involved. JD Vance is the natural heir apparent in the eyes of many Trump loyalists. He has the vice-presidential title, the political platform and the necessary transformation story, having travelled from a critic of Trumpism to one of its most committed defenders. His political calculations are hardly difficult to understand. He has positioned himself as the man who can inherit the movement without having to inherit every single one of Trump's personal eccentricities.

Marco Rubio, meanwhile, has undergone his own remarkable political metamorphosis. Once a presidential rival and a critic of Trump's political instincts, he has become an indispensable member of the administration, occupying multiple positions of responsibility and demonstrating an impressive capacity for political adaptation. Rubio brings experience, diplomatic polish and a conventional Republican appearance that might reassure sections of the party uncomfortable with the prospect of another Trump-style personality cult. But neither man owns the movement. They rent their political authority from its founder.

And that is the fundamental problem with this succession exercise. Trump has built a political organisation in which loyalty to the leader frequently matters more than competence, independent judgement or institutional responsibility. The candidates are not being measured primarily by their ability to govern a country of more than 330 million people. They are being measured by their ability to remain acceptable to Donald Trump.

Miller's unexpected prominence exposes another dimension. The question is not simply who succeeds Trump, but which version of Trumpism survives him. Vance offers an electoral and populist vehicle. Rubio offers administrative experience and international credibility. Miller offers ideological continuity, with an agenda that does not necessarily require a presidential personality to keep it moving.

There is a danger in treating this as harmless political entertainment. The American presidency is not a corporate boardroom, the vice-presidency is not a waiting room, and the machinery of government is not a production studio where the executive producer can change the cast whenever the ratings decline.

Yet Trump continues to personalise American politics as though the country were his private franchise. His political allies compete for approval, his opponents become enemies, and institutions are expected to accommodate the emotional requirements of the man at the centre of the spectacle.

The truly disturbing question is not whether Vance or Rubio will eventually get the job. It is whether either will inherit the presidency as an institution or merely inherit Trump's television studio, complete with its personality cult, ideological grudges and permanent casting competition.

For now, the auditions continue. Vance is waiting for his cue, Rubio is polishing his lines, and Miller has discovered that he may not need to be the leading actor to control the production. And Trump? He remains the executive producer, director, principal performer and sole judge. America, meanwhile, is expected to keep paying for the tickets.


No comments:

The Black Sea blind spot by Harry S. Taylor

Europe’s next defence frontier is not where Brussels has been looking. And Russia knows it. Europe has spent years looking northwards, towa...